Zorant - My comments on midi | The best of Russian midi

on midi Panamarjov Oleg - «Atir17»

01-06-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Еxciting music with a very peaceful middle section.

02-06-2011 Panamarjov Oleg:
Many thanks, Zoran!

on midi Panamarjov Oleg - «Rondo a la Turqa(turetskiy marsh)» 2 version

07-05-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Interesting arrangement! I especially liked the clarinet melody starting at 1:40 (it reminds mi of a marching band) and piano roll at 2:04. Only deficiency I noted is too quiet sounding (too low main volume) of your last two songs (which is probably due to your equipment). Greetings. Bravo!

07-05-2011 Panamarjov Oleg:
Many thanks, Zoran!

Too low main volume of last two songs(accepted) is due to my laziness to listen it the last time before laying out it on(I promise to be corrected

on midi Panamarjov Oleg - «Progulka»

29-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Очень спокойная прогулка

There is a wrong guitar note (accompaniment) at 1:29 which is slightly disturbing.

29-04-2011 Panamarjov Oleg:
Thanks, Zoran!

Sorry, I've examined the whole step up&down, criss&cross but have found nothing. If you mean big second C+D,then they are quite supposed together in a sept-harmony of a chord in one step or a share.
P.S* Or we haven't understood each other

Nevertheless, thanks.

29-04-2011 Zorant:
Track 6, tact 40, you have 3 notes gis2 and they create major not minor harmony. Insted of gis2 you need fis2 for first two notes and g2 for the third (at list I think so .

)

29-04-2011 Panamarjov Oleg:
Right you are Zoran, thanks! Some steps of track 6 I corrected after transposing, that's why, perhaps...(roof on one side)
Once more, THANNN-K-SSS!

30-04-2011 Zorant:
You are

(but better don't

)

on midi Tsirjuk Pavel - «Molitva»

27-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

The melody is too broken at times but still enjoyable for listening.

10-05-2011 Tsirjuk Pavel:
Спасибо, Zoran! Приятна и полезна.

on midi Radda - «On ne pozvonil»

27-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Excellent harmonies, subtle feelings. I like it.

on midi Korotyshev Il\'ja - «Dozhdi»

27-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Simple but nice. Very peaceful music.

on midi Mazan Juliа - «Val's pervoklassnikov»

27-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Nice music. Could be used as film music for an old Hollywood movie.

17-05-2011 Mazan Juliа:
Спасибо.

on midi Panamarjov Oleg - «Kuplety» 3 version

24-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

The original is unknown to me but this sounds interesting and enjoyable. I think (I've tried) that without drums is even better.

06-05-2011 Panamarjov Oleg:
Thanks, Zoran!

Perhaps, you're right. It's a kind of russian chastooshkas.

on midi Panamarjov Oleg - «Am(survived)»

24-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

Variations, too melodic for a classical organ (thankfully). I like it just because of the pretty melodies.

06-05-2011 Panamarjov Oleg:
Thanks, Zoran!

Originally it was a song about an old musician. I also liked it.There are very few my opuses which still are pleasant to me.

on midi Super-Antoshka - «Something» 2 version

20-04-2011 Zorant (Basic user)

The accompaniment is great, especialy the rhythm guitar. I do not like much the main vocal timbre (Solo vox or Lead vocal). Maybe some woodwind instrument will do better. Greetings.

21-04-2011 Super-Antoshka:
I agree with you about the rude sound of Lead 6 (voice), but it's my considered opinion.
Once upon a time I've arrived at an idea that MIDI is not a music but just a standard, so I makes it most with mind, not an ears.

Actually in compromise.
Anyway thanks Zoran!

21-04-2011 Zorant:
Yes you're right; one must have great imagination and great love for music to be able to withstand the funny sound of the midi music. Fortunately there are such freaks.